Campaigning for Labour to back proportional representation


Log in

ABOUT LCER

Our vision and values

Our vision is of a participatory democracy in which everyone feels they have a meaningful stake; and of a politics which works to bring our society together.

We believe that this can only be achieved by scrapping the First Past the Post voting system, and replacing it with a more proportional system in which all votes count.

First Past the Post makes for a polarised politics which is adversarial, tribal and toxic, and which does not represent people. We seek to replace it with a system which encourages consensus-seeking, cooperation and problem-solving.

We support the Labour Party’s commitment to a Constitutional Convention to examine the case for a wide set of democratic reforms; we are campaigning to ensure that the Convention includes as its centrepiece a commitment to a fair voting system.

Why THE Labour PARTY must take the lead
on PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION

LCER works with other organisations campaigning for democratic reform, but we are unique in focusing our efforts on policy change within the Labour Party. We do this because we believe that the impetus for changing the voting system must come from the Labour Party.

The Conservatives will NEVER support voting reform because FPTP gives them such a big electoral advantage. The anti-Tory vote is often split between two or more parties; Labour also tends to pile up surplus votes in urban areas (see table below).

The smaller parties already support PR, but lack the influence to bring about change.

Only Labour can drive the change

LABOUR'S WASTED VOTES

  Labour MPS
 Tory MPs
 MPs with over 60% of the vote
 87 7
 MPs with over 70% of the vote
 24 0
 MPs with over 80% of the vote
 5 0
 Average vote share achieved by winning MPs
 56.3% 49.1%

In the 2017 election, 87 Labour MPs were elected with over 60% of the votes cast in their constituency. 24 of these got over 70% of votes cast, while 5 MPs got over 80%!

By contrast, only 7 Tory MPs were elected with over 60% of the vote and no Tory MP received over 64% of the vote.

This is not just a problem with the 2017 UK election - it is a known problem with FPTP systems. They disadvantage left-leaning voters because they are disproportionately likely to live in densely populated urban areas. 

What do we mean by a "proportional" voting system?

LCER believes that the composition of Parliament should broadly match the way that people voted. A party that gets (say) 25% of the vote should get roughly 25% of the seats in Parliament.

Many countries around the world use voting systems that are completely proportional - that is, they are designed to ensure the closest possible match between the votes cast and the seats won by each party.

Other countries use voting systems which have a strong degree of proportionality, but which give a small boost to the largest party (or possibly the two largest parties). This is known as a "winner's bonus" and can make it easier to form a government after an election.

Experts have developed a range of indices for measuring the degree of proportionality in different voting systems. The results vary slightly according to the exact measure used, and can even vary between different elections that use the same system. But all the experts agree on one thing: First Past the Post is the least proportional system around.

LCER does not campaign for the introduction of any particular electoral system; we believe that the final choice of voting system should rest with a broadly-based Constitutional Convention. In particular, we are not campaigning for a completely proportional voting system; we believe that the UK would probably be better served by a broadly proportional system that maintained a strong local link between MPs and their constituents.

Our campaigns focus on the need for for an incoming Labour government to ditch First Past the Post and to replace it with a voting system that is fair, broadly proportional, and that suits the needs of the UK. 

CONTACT

Postal address: 
84 Cranbrook Road, Bristol BS6 7DB

Email:
lcer@labourcampaignforelectoralreform.org.uk


Phone:  0117 924 5139;  07712 511931

Website https://www.labourcampaignforelectoralreform.org.uk

Copyright © LCER

FOLLOW LCER

SEARCH SITE

Campaigning for Labour to back
proportional representation

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software